The method
How we value a company
Every value of a stock you see on OffHours, in the Buy Zone, in a report and in the daily email, comes from the same arithmetic. No judgment hides in it. This page says what the arithmetic is, in plain words, and works it through on a real company with the numbers we hold tonight.
The six steps
- Start with the cash the whole business produces. Take the cash left after the business pays for its own equipment, and add back what it paid its lenders in interest, after tax. That is the cash the company makes before anyone with a claim on it is paid.
- Pick a starting level. Usually the average of the last five years, so one good or bad year does not decide everything. When the last four quarters came in well below that average, and the business itself produced less, not just spent more on equipment, the lower figure is the start. We say which rule applied.
- Set the yearly return the money must earn. Owners of the shares demand one return, lenders are paid another. We weigh the two by how much of the company each group funds at today's prices. A business carrying debt equal to its market value is half funded by lenders, and its rate says so.When a company's debt is larger than the value of all its shares, the market treats it as in trouble and the return demanded goes up: shareholders ask 4% more a year, and the debt is costed at what a stressed borrower would pay to borrow today, at least 10.3% before tax. The usual cap on the return for the company's industry does not apply then; it can only push the rate up. A fall in the share price does not change the rate: the value must not depend on the price it is judging.
- Value the whole company. Grow the starting cash for 10 years at a chosen rate, add a value for every year after that, and bring it all back to today's money at the return from step three.
- Pay the lenders, then divide by the shares. Debt minus cash comes off the whole-company value first. What remains belongs to shareholders, and divided by the share count it is a value per share. A company with more cash than debt gets the difference added.
- Run it backwards to read the market. Today's price times the shares, plus the debt, is what the market says the whole company is worth. We find the yearly growth that makes step four equal that number. That is "what the market expects".
Three cases come from the same steps: a bad case with slower growth and less cash, the middle path, and a good case. The bad case is the "worst-case value" you see beside a price. These are model outputs, never predictions, and the method never says buy or sell.
The bad case is never milder than what today's price already assumes. When the price only makes sense if the cash shrinks every year, and that shrinking is faster than our bad case, the bad case is set to the market's own figure (never steeper than a 20% fall a year), with the same cut to cash on top. A worst case that sits above the price would otherwise be a cushion that does not exist.
Worked example: BellRing Brands, Inc. (BRBR)
Numbers as stored at the Nov 20 close. They change every trading day.
- Share price
- $14.57
- All the shares together
- $1.70 billion (116 million shares)
- Debt minus cash
- $1.08 billion
- latest filing Jun 30
- What the market says the whole company is worth
- $2.78 billion
- shares plus net debt
- Cash the whole business produces (starting level)
- $269 million
- five-year average
- Same cash, last four quarters
- $279 million
- Return shareholders demand
- 7.7%
- Cost of the debt, after tax
- 4.8%
- lenders fund 40% of the company at today's prices
- Blended yearly return the money must earn
- 6.5%
- Growth assumed after year ten
- 2.7%
What the market expects. For the whole-company value to equal $2.78 billion, the cash above would have to change by about -8.8% a year for 10 years. Over its own record the business's sales grew 16.8% a year.
Three cases, per share, after the debt. If things go badly (-8.8% growth and 10% less cash): $12.18. The middle path (18.6%): $215.65. If things go well (22.3%): $290.84. Today's price is $14.57. The bad case is held to the -8.8% a year the price itself assumes, because our usual bad case was milder than that. The nightly figures scale the middle path from the growth the business delivered; a Dive Deep report holds it to what the company itself says to expect, which is usually lower.
Why debt matters here: with $1.08 billion of net debt against $1.70 billion of shares, a method that ignored the debt would have called this company worth $224.97 a share on the middle path instead of $215.65.
What this is not
A value is an output of the inputs above. Change the starting cash, the return demanded or the growth, and the value moves, often a lot. The point of showing the steps is that you can disagree with one and see what follows. The Dive Deep report and the questions it asks you exist for exactly that.
Banks and insurers are not valued this way; their cash flows do not mean the same thing, and their rows say "n/m" instead of a number. Reports and personal numbers written before Nov 3 used an earlier method, after-interest cash with no debt line, and are labelled so where they still appear.
Market assumptions: 4.3% risk-free rate, 5.5% premium for owning shares, 21% tax rate on interest, reviewed Sep 11. Everything else comes from the company's filings and today's price. See the values in the Buy Zone →